What Your Penis Might Be Telling You

You know when your penis works, when it doesn’t, or when it surprises you. What we often overlook is that changes in sexual functioning can act as signals. Psychologist and sex therapist Daniel Watter, in The Existential Importance of the Penis, suggests that erections, loss of desire, or sudden compulsions sometimes carry messages from deeper layers of the mind. These messages often reflect safety, fear, or old patterns of coping rather than a simple “performance problem.”

Drawing on existential psychotherapist Irvin Yalom, Watter encourages us to see sexual difficulties as meaningful. An erectile shutdown with a partner we care about, for example, might signal fear of rejection, fear of being overwhelmed, or the reactivation of earlier wounds. Desire that suddenly feels overwhelming can be the body’s way of managing feelings of vulnerability or loss of control. Instead of treating these changes as malfunctions, therapy views them as responses worth exploring.

For gay men, these signals are often layered. Many of us carry early experiences of shame, rejection from family or peers, and constant exposure to cultural rules about masculinity. On top of that, hookup culture and body ideals add pressure to perform sexually with ease. In this environment, a penis that “goes quiet” with someone we want to connect with—but works with a stranger—may be protecting us from deeper fears of intimacy.

Compulsive sexual behavior can serve a similar function. Watter notes that hypersexuality often acts as a defense against feelings of vulnerability, mortality, or powerlessness. Michael Bader, writing about sexual fantasy, goes further: he views sexual scenarios as unconscious attempts to resolve emotional dilemmas. Seen this way, even the fantasies or behaviors that confuse us may highlight fears of closeness, struggles with power, or longings that feel unsafe to express directly.

Sexual difficulties are not simply “in your head.” The penis is part of the body, and bodies send signals in their own language. The useful questions are: Why this experience? Why this partner? Why now? Exploring these questions in therapy can uncover how sexual responses connect to past relationships, unresolved fears of intimacy, or strategies developed earlier in life to avoid pain. They may point toward fear of rejection, discomfort with closeness, or the return of old wounds.

When erections feel unreliable, desire feels out of balance, or sex leaves you unsatisfied, the invitation is to listen rather than push harder. Therapy offers a place to slow down and understand what your sexuality may be protecting, expressing, or searching for. With support, it becomes possible to connect the dots between sexual responses and the rest of life—and to build a more grounded, fulfilling relationship with yourself and others.

---

If you’d like support in making sense of these experiences, reach out for a free 15-minute consultation.